Unethical? Unnecessary? The COVID-19 vaccine booster debate intensifies

As United States reveals its plan to offer an extra dose of COVID-19 vaccine, equity and scientific questions abound

The greater infectiousness of the Delta variant of SARS-CoV-2 has scientists and governments debating whether booster shots of COVID-19 vaccines are needed in some countries given limited vaccine supplies elsewhere.AHMAD GHARABLI/AFP VIA GETTY IMAGES

As the extraordinarily infectious Delta variant of SARS-CoV-2 continues to spread around the world, vaccines’ powers are showing their limits. Although they are still extremely effective at preventing severe COVID-19, the tantalizing hope that the shots could block almost all infections—and squelch transmission—has evaporated. That has upended return to office and school plans, threatened economic recoveries, and spurred fresh political rows over mask and vaccination mandates.

Now, amid hints that vaccine-induced immunity is waning, policymakers and scientists are debating whether widespread booster shots could help—or whether getting shots into the arms of the unvaccinated should remain the top priority. And many people wonder whether one booster will suffice or periodic COVID-19 vaccination will become the new normal, as it is for influenza.

On the latter question, some scientists say experience with other vaccines suggests a single well-timed booster may provide long-lasting immunity. But others contend the booster rush is premature given scant data on their effectiveness and best timing. “We don’t understand who is going to need a booster, how long after their last dose, or which vaccine combination works best,” says physician-epidemiologist Bruce Aylward, a senior adviser at the World Health Organization (WHO). “You need to understand all that before you decide how boosters should be used.”

That hasn’t stopped booster rollouts in countries like Israel, which is seeing a Delta-fueled surge of COVID-19 cases, hospitalizations, and deaths, despite one of the earliest and fastest vaccine campaigns in the world. More than 60% of the Israeli population has received two doses of Pfizer’s messenger RNA (mRNA) vaccine, but on 30 July, Israel began to offer a third dose of the vaccine to anyone 60 and older—the first country to do so. On 20 August, it said everyone 40 and older should get one.

WHO and other organizations have warned strongly against such broad booster rollouts, mainly because many high-risk people worldwide have not even received a first vaccine dose. Giving boosters now is unfair to say the least, potentially … even criminal', says Tulio de Oliveira, a computational biologist at the University of KwaZulu-Natal, Durban, who has used sequencing to track the pandemic’s spread in Africa.

The United States and several other countries have started to give boosters to people with weakened immune responses or at high risk of developing serious COVID-19. Some regions are also recommending boosters for health care workers, as even mild breakthrough cases can hobble the health system if staff have to isolate. Giving a third dose to those smaller groups is less controversial; the expected benefits are somewhat clearer, and the numbers of COVID-19 vaccine doses required only have a marginal impact on global supplies, Aylward says.

But other wealthy countries may well follow Israel’s lead and make boosters available to nearly everyone. On 18 August, just days before the U.S. Food and Drug Administration gave full approval to Pfizer’s COVID-19 vaccine, the Biden administration said it would provide boosters more broadly in September, although that would first require approval by FDA and by a U.S. panel that recommends which specific populations should receive immunizations.

You are reducing supply for those who need it more.


Many vaccine experts argue there isn’t enough evidence that boosters are needed or will truly help control the pandemic, especially because multiple studies show existing vaccine regimens are holding strong against severe disease. A large study of patient health records in New York state, published on 18 August in the Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, found that vaccine efficacy against all SARS-CoV-2 infections dropped from 91.7% to 79.8% between May and July, as Delta took over in the region. But protection against hospitalization for COVID-19 stayed close to 95%. Data from the Israeli Ministry of Health suggests protection against severe disease is still nearly 92% for people 50 and younger and 85% for those older than 50.

That suggests boosters are the wrong way to use the world’s still limited vaccine supply, says Aylward, who helps coordinate the COVID-19 Vaccines Global Access Facility, which distributes doses to low- and middle-income countries. If everyone in high-income countries received boosters, that would use up 1 billion doses, Aylward estimates. “You’re dealing with a finite, zero-sum resource,” he says. “You are reducing supply for those who need it more.”

Even preparing for possible boosters disrupts the supply and distribution system, he says, as countries stock up on extra doses. “The U.K. has 66 million people and recently bought another 110 million doses—and they already have 80% of the [eligible] population vaccinated,” de Oliveira says, “while at the moment Africa is at less than 3%.”

Others don’t deny that boosting in rich countries might disadvantage the rest of the world, but say that, scientifically speaking, a third dose is likely to help shore up the immune system. “[Vaccine] efficacy drops with Delta. That is indisputable,” especially for mild disease, says Leif Erik Sander, an infectious disease expert at the Charité University Hospital in Berlin.

Other vaccines require three shots to confer long-lasting protection, including those for hepatitis B and tick-borne encephalitis. And some scientists have suggested the current COVID-19 vaccine dose spacing—just 3 to 4 weeks between mRNA doses, for example—was chosen not to provide long-lasting immunity, but to speed clinical testing. A boost months later may be ideal, they say, and doesn’t necessarily mean yearly updates will be needed. Although SARS-CoV-2 is evolving in dangerous ways, it does not seem to undergo the same type of genetic shuffling flu viruses do in other animals.

“A third dose is a good idea,” says Akiko Iwasaki, an immunologist at Yale University. Although at-risk groups should receive them first, she adds, “if there are enough doses, I think the general public will benefit,” both because they are likely to help reduce SARS-CoV-2’s spread and because even mild COVID-19 can lead to long-term complications.

In Israel, there are signs that the third shots are reducing infections in older people. “The very preliminary data look like it is having an effect,” says Barak Raveh, who studies dynamic systems at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. His analysis of the Health Ministry’s data suggests protection against SARS-CoV-2 infection for vaccinated people has climbed in recent weeks, likely driven by boosters; 80% of people in their 70s have already received a third dose.

There’s no telling how long that fortified immune shield will last. Multiple trials are underway to more precisely measure the effects of boosters—including mixing and matching different types of COVID-19 vaccines—but they will likely take several more months. As with so much in the pandemic, policymakers will have to make far-reaching decisions long before clear answers are in.

News date: 2021-08-27



KRISP has been created by the coordinated effort of the University of KwaZulu-Natal (UKZN), the Technology Innovation Agency (TIA) and the South African Medical Research Countil (SAMRC).

Location: K-RITH Tower Building
Nelson R Mandela School of Medicine, UKZN
719 Umbilo Road, Durban, South Africa.
Director: Prof. Tulio de Oliveira